Boston's Hidden Restaurants

Questions and Answers >> Boston Restaurants -- General Topics >> Favorite Roast Beef Joint?

Favorite Roast Beef Joint?

(From Our Questions and Answers Feature)

Who do you think makes the best roast beef sandwich in the Boston area? Any outside of the North Shore worth mentioning? [Go here to post a reply.]
(Posted by hiddenboston)

REPLIES (last updated ):

Ken M wrote:
Mike's Roast Beef on 99 in Everett

Mike wrote:
went to college in beverly... nicks roast beef is and always will be the best.

DRubin wrote:
Bill and Bob's in Woburn and Malden/Saugus? A lot of these places have essentially the same offerings. Mike's, Nick's, Liberty Bell but the details make some better than others. I like a well grilled, crispy bun which I gotta eat before the sauce get it too soggy. James River is the best bbq sauce served at a lot of these places

DAS wrote:
Harrison's in North Andover. Perfection.

GP wrote:
The original Kelly's in Revere.

@dcm520 wrote:
Roast Beast in Packard's Corner is definitely the best, with their secret beast sauce.

kev wrote:
American Provisions in South Boston. It's called the "Boursin & the Beast"

RCL wrote:
Nick's in Beverly da best! I miss Reilly's though. Double deluxe suicide.

TBE wrote:
Roast Beast by Packard's... the blissful plight of countless BU student's diets.

sirois65 wrote:
billy's roast beef wakefield

eh wrote:
Roast Beast is the best. onion roll, horseradish sauce, vermont cheddar.

KM wrote:
Billy's in Wakefield or Harrison's North Andover

SBS wrote:
Kelly's in Revere hands down!

RW wrote:
But you gotta get to Chicago and have an Italian Beef....

Tunse wrote:
Roast beef sandwich sliced right at the bar at the Mount Vernon Somerville, just over the C Town line.

nc wrote:
Billy's in Wakefield

WB wrote:
I've always been a Mike's in Everett, guy, but I've always heard good things about Nick's. The place in Eastie, Royal, is a sleeper....

pete wrote:
Jillian's in Lowell, MA

SB wrote:
Nick's Beverly, Billy's Wakefield, Harrison's North Andover.... In that order

RJL wrote:
Roast Beast on Commonwealth Avenue in Boston is in a league of its own. It owns Roast Beef sandwiches.

PnyLn wrote:
As far as Cambridge goes, Skampa on Cambridge St is pretty great!

RCL wrote:
Nick's up in Beverly. Period.

Randy L. wrote:
Nick's up in Beverly. Period.

Josh T. wrote:
Nick's. Done.

Steve S. wrote:
billy's melrose

@jsilva982 wrote:
@nicksbeverly without a doubt. I lived in DC for 5 years and Nick's would be my first stop after touching down at Logan.

George P. wrote:

DC wrote:
Harrison's North Andover

jeanc wrote:
Beachmont roast beef..under Beachmont T station. BETTER than Kelly's!

@jibbajabba99 wrote:
@cuttys roast beef 1000! Can't be beat...

@MartyMcCabe wrote:
Cuttys in Brookline. @cuttys. A thousand times Cuttys.

Pat M. wrote:
Royal east boston. Nothing else comes close

@JosephVictor81 wrote:
Peter's Roast Beef in Revere

@camozzi_joe wrote:
Prime Roast Beef and Seafood in Lexington. Large on an onion roll with a little horseradish. Perfection.
Cutty's is fantastic too! The Roast Beef 1000 is terrific. I can have two favorite places, right?

Frederick W. wrote:
No question: Royal Roast Beef on Bennington for traditional.
Roast Beast for yupscale.
Kelly's for tourists.

Bryan wrote:
King's Roast Beef in Salem MA! Awesome !!

miket wrote:
Used to be Royals in eastie but they've been slacking a little lately so the original kellys on revere beach is my new fave

Chantel wrote:
Roastbeast in Allston MA

Rich D. wrote:
Royal house in Methuen has a good sandwich

Karen K wrote:
Harrison's North Andover

PigTrip BBQ wrote:
Different style, but Cutty's in Brookline.

Lynne H. wrote:
Mount Vernon has an amazing Roast beef sandwich...its in a lightly buttered and grilled roll...nice medium rare roast beef..then they give you a cup of au jus to dip it in...Amazing!!! Also im not sure if it was only that day but it was 8.95 with fries and a draft beer!!! So so good!!

William E. wrote:
Beefmaster in Billerica....hottest horseradish sauce I've had. Super w/ cheese, hot horseradish and BBQ sauce is my standard order.

Christina M. D. wrote:
Georgio's in Brockton

Stacia D. wrote:
Mimi's in Malden!

Lisa C. wrote:
Mike's in Everett

@BC_Husker wrote:
kings in Salem is pretty amazing. Non-north shore entry is Simard's in Wilmington. Very serviceable.

@Bfklin wrote:
royale roast beef Eastie

@STWatkins78 wrote:
Roast Beast on Commonwealth and Naples...SAM V ftw

@TownsmanJordan wrote:
Roast Beast in Allston is tops.

@Life_As_KG wrote:
gaveston's cafe in marina bay, Quincy! Best Vietnamese food in mass!

@Jason_Has_Ideas wrote:
Best in Boston is Roast Beast in Allston, but best in Mass is Serio's in Northampton, get the El Toro:

@Sherridacherry wrote:
Kelly's in Revere will always be my favorite!

@itisbenjamin wrote:
@cuttys roast beef is the best I've ever had. I wish it was twice as big.

@PFEskeets wrote:
Billy's in Wakefield. The best hands down.

@k8droste wrote:
definitely @cuttys

@mcm743 wrote:
roast beast near BU is amazing

@Chase79Chris wrote:
Billy's in Wakefield, Harrison's in N Andover and Nicks in Beverly are all on par with each other and have the BEST

JMB wrote:
Royals Roast beef #1 stoneham
mikes Everett #2
Meme #3 Malden
Alamos #4 Medford

k8droste wrote:
definitely cuttys

k8droste wrote:
Beachmont, the King of all Beef...

Wile E. wrote:
definitely cuttys

JMH wrote:

mike b wrote:
Roast Beast. Those guys are awesome.

Doodle M wrote:
Blue House Roast Beef in Salem, NH. Their sandwiches are delicious as well as gigantic.

Paul J. wrote:
Royall Roast Beef in East Boston!!!

Patrick D. wrote:
Don't forget Kellys or Nicks roast beef as well!

Zachary A. wrote:
Kings and Nicks are a tie. I will put Kings fingers up against Nicks any day.

Dan M. wrote:
Cambridge. Tender, flavorful, cheap.

Lynne H. wrote:
Mount Vernon has an amazing special on the bar side...8.95. A big roast beef sandwich with au jus to dip in...served w fries or rings and a beer!!!!! I go at least once a week...bring friends that dont drink so you can drink their beer!!

Daniel G. wrote:
Kelly's ain't what it used to be. Royal in East Boston and Beachmont Roast Beef in Revere still offer up a quality sandwich.

Monique A. wrote:
Royal Roast Beef!!

Kevin M. wrote:
Mike's Roast Beef in Everett paired with waffle fries and nacho cheese

Samantha M. wrote:
BeefMaster roast beef and seafood up in Billerica! To die for!

Chris R. wrote:
Nick's Roast Beef - North Beverly

Ellen N. H. wrote:
Roast Beast in Allston

Lisa C. wrote:
Mike's in Everett

Buster M. wrote:
Love Kelly's!!!

@James13rown wrote:
Mike's Place, Saugus. The best.

@katerinahillios wrote:
NICKS ROAST BEEF @nicksbeverly

@joeyballs825 wrote:
no question Kellys!

Trems ‏@_Trems_ wrote:
Land and Sea in Peabody

Neil wrote:
Nicks in Beverly, Harrisons in North Andover and Nikos in Salisbury.

SZ Donut Boy wrote:
Billy's in Wakefield

Land N' Sea - PEABODY

matt c wrote:
No love for Land and Sea in South Peabody. Place is the best!

J.C. wrote:
Get the Old North Church at My Cousin's Place in the North End. Best roast beef sandwich in Boston.

bill wrote:
Kipos roast beef in Wakefield. Def a must have!!

lm wrote:
Land & Sea Peabody Ma Best roast beef & Seafood in North Shore by far everything always fresh and good service too

TEH wrote:
Nick's in Beverly!

Strauss wrote:
Mike's in Everett without a doubt. The ideal sandwich. Better than Kelly's, Skampa, Nick's, Cutty's, Roast Beast, Billy's, all of them, no question.


Note: Reader posts are now coming from Facebook and Twitter questions that are occasionally posted on this subject.